Setter of the Year
Big Ten · Season honor
Winners12 wins
| Year | Player | Team | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | Bergen Reilly | Nebraska | S |
| 2024 | Bergen Reilly | Nebraska | S |
| 2023 | Bergen Reilly | Nebraska | S |
| 2022 | Mac Podraza | Ohio State | S |
| 2021 | Sydney Hilley | Wisconsin | S |
| 2020 | Sydney Hilley | Wisconsin | S |
| 2019 | Sydney Hilley | Wisconsin | S |
| 2018 | Jordyn Poulter | Illinois | S |
| 2015 | Lauren Carlini | Wisconsin | S |
| 2014 | Lauren Carlini | Wisconsin | S |
| 2013 | Micha Hancock | Penn State | S |
| 2012 | Micha Hancock | Penn State | S |